NewsDesk World

Press releases and business news from around the world

Offered with kind assistance from

Many EV Fleets Rely on Drivers' Word for Charging Costs

Professional · Updated ·

A survey of 250 fleet, finance and procurement leaders found that 44% of electric fleets take drivers at their word on home charging costs, which exposes operators to expenses fraud.

Many EV Fleets Rely on Drivers' Word for Charging Costs

Almost half of electric vehicle fleets, 44%, rely on drivers to say how much they spend charging at home, according to a new survey. That leaves operators open to expenses fraud.

Confidence ahead of control

Mobility software firm Cubic3 commissioned the survey. It covered 250 fleet, finance and procurement leaders. Of them, 93% said they could identify unauthorised or fraudulent spend, and 64% believed they had full visibility of costs. Only 41% said their expenses were under control, and 34% had trouble tracking spend accurately across vehicles and drivers.

Paul Foley, Cubic3's vice-president of in-vehicle payments, called that mismatch the heart of the matter: "The gap between confidence and control is the real finding." Fleets, he said, should check a payment against company rules before it is made, not reconcile it once the money has gone.

Why the official rates miss

Reimbursing home charging has long been hard for fleets, which helps explain why self-reporting is the most popular way to claim the money back. Energy used at home is hard to split out of a household's utility bill. HMRC-approved advisory electric rates come out each quarter, and home charging and public charging get their own per-mile figures. They are meant to let claims go through without argument.

The rates are approximate by nature, though. A driver on an Ofgem-capped tariff of 26.3p per kWh would need to average 3.8 miles per kWh, charging losses included, to break even with the 7p per-mile home rate. Drivers who charge on cheap overnight tariffs, which typically bring costs below 2p per mile, are heavily over-reimbursed by the same rate.

Claims no one could check

In the last 12 months, 48% of the leaders had expenses claims they could not verify. Over the same period, 31% reported unauthorised transactions on company credit, fuel or charging cards. And 30% had at least one suspected or confirmed case of fraud.

Electrification is adding to the strain. According to the survey, 54% said EV charging made payment and spend management more complicated, and that work already costs 171 hours a year on average.

More EVs, same blind spot

Respondents expect EVs to average 49% of their fleets within the next three years. Cubic3 warned that the oversight risks becoming an increasingly large issue for operators.

HMRC's guidance lets operators set their own rates. They would need to prove the figures match real-world costs, or any excess may be counted as untaxed income.

Just 20% of the surveyed fleets use a tariff or a meter to work out what home charging costs.

Source: Autocar