NewsDesk World

Press releases and business news from around the world

Delivered with the aid of sponsors

Posey Joins 2027 Baseball Hall of Fame Ballot With 26 Others

US Sports · Updated ·

The 2027 BBWAA Hall of Fame ballot has 13 holdovers and 14 newcomers, led by Buster Posey. Results come on Jan. 19, with induction at Cooperstown over the summer.

Posey Joins 2027 Baseball Hall of Fame Ballot With 26 Others

The Baseball Writers' Association of America has released its 2027 Hall of Fame ballot, with 13 holdovers and 14 newcomers. A CBS Sports writer expects Buster Posey and Chase Utley to be elected.

The call on Posey and Utley

The writer calls Posey a lock and does not think his numbers need a deep dive. Posey played in parts of only 12 seasons, yet the writer still thinks he gets in. Utley is the second pick. The writer also calls the ballot relatively weak, especially once the stain of PED suspicion on some players is counted.

Utley is in his fourth year and needs 15.9 more points after jumping nearly 20 last cycle. Last year Carlos Beltrán and Andruw Jones were elected, and this year there is only one strong first-year candidate. In a thin field, the writer argues, the best players can post big gains, and Utley might make it in or come close enough to be elected in 2028.

Voter habits explain why a weak ballot matters. Many voters set their own cap, such as three names per ballot, and some turn in blank ones.

Names at the end of the road

Omar Vizquel is on his 10th and final ballot after slipping to 18.4% last year. Torii Hunter hovers just above the 5% line, with 8.7% last year in his sixth try. Others returning are Bobby Abreu at 30.8%, Jimmy Rollins at 25.4%, Dustin Pedroia at 20.7% and David Wright at 14.8%.

The reliever test case

Relievers face a high bar. Billy Wagner got in recently on his last BBWAA try. Francisco Rodríguez has appeared four times and drawn between 7.8% and 11.8%. He sits sixth on the career saves list, and the writer rates his rate stats as good. The writer watches him as a signal for three active closers: Kenley Jansen is third in saves with similar innings, Craig Kimbrel is fifth with more than 100 fewer innings, and Aroldis Chapman is ninth, near Kimbrel in workload. If K-Rod stalls, the question is whether they will too.

Starters and A-Rod

The writer wants a lower standard for modern starters, since workloads have shrunk. Andy Pettitte got 48.5% in his eighth try. Félix Hernández went from 20.6% to 46.1% in his second year. Cole Hamels drew 23.8% in his first, and Mark Buehrle jumped to 20% last year after sitting between 5.8% and 11.4%.

Alex Rodriguez is in year six. The writer says his numbers rank him among the 10 best position players ever, but PED ties keep him out. He moved from 37.1% in 2025 to 40%, a new high. If he reaches the 50% range, the writer says, a deeper conversation is in order.

Newcomers and the rules

Among the first-timers, Jon Lester has the best case. The writer points to how voters have treated comparable starting pitchers in recent years and expects him to hang around on the ballot, but sees a major uphill fight to get in. Gardner, Zimmerman, Seager, Arrieta and Miller are expected to miss the 5% needed to return.

A candidate needs 75% of ballots cast to be elected. Staying on requires 5%, and nobody gets more than 10 cycles. The BBWAA vote covers players retired at least five years. Others get another look from committees, as Jeff Kent did last year. This time a Contemporary Baseball Committee for managers, umpires and executives meets on Dec. 6. The BBWAA results come on Jan. 19.

Source: CBS Sports