NewsDesk World

Press releases and business news from around the world

Shared with the kind help of

Inquiry Finds Decades of Abuse at Edinburgh Academy

Crime · ·

A report from Scotland's child abuse inquiry names four serial perpetrators at the school and finds that staff avoided acting on obvious signs of abuse.

Inquiry Finds Decades of Abuse at Edinburgh Academy

The Scottish Child Abuse Inquiry has found that pupils at Edinburgh Academy suffered sexual, physical and emotional abuse over more than 40 years. Its chair, Lady Smith, says the school put its reputation first and ignored complaints.

Four perpetrators and nearly 50 witnesses

Lady Smith, a former judge, names four serial perpetrators. Two went on to offend at other schools. The private school faced claims about 20 teachers, and most of the evidence covers 1954 to 1995. Nearly 50 witnesses spoke to the inquiry. One was broadcaster Nicky Campbell, who said one teacher had abused children on an "industrial scale".

The report says sexual abuse ran from the 1950s to the 1980s and included children abusing other children. Physical abuse was normalised. Prep school children were regularly beaten until corporal punishment ended in 1988. After co-education arrived in the sixth form, girls faced misogyny and abuse.

A school that did not look at itself

Lady Smith said the school failed for decades to examine itself realistically. It assumed abuse would not take place, she found. When complaints were made they were disbelieved or left unresolved, and staff avoided investigation despite obvious signs.

As recently as 2001 the school's Court of Directors was focused on its reputation and how it was seen, rather than on pupils' lives. The report found no evidence that the school considered the obvious risks.

One housemaster's eccentric classroom behaviour was known and celebrated by the school, according to the report. Items he had used to abuse pupils were auctioned when he left.

The named staff

Two long-serving staff are named as abusers: Hamish Dawson, a housemaster and senior school teacher, and John Brownlee, a housemaster and deputy head of the junior school. It also singles out prep school teacher Iain Wares, who later abused pupils at Fettes College and now awaits extradition from South Africa. A fourth, physics teacher William Bain, has twice been convicted of sex offences. He began his history of abuse at Edinburgh Academy before harming children in other schools.

One pupil's account

The report highlights evidence from a pupil using the pseudonym Henry, who spent nine years at the school. He said abuse was part of daily life. Pastoral care and safeguarding were absent, he told the inquiry, and bullying, racism, sexism and homophobia went unchecked.

Lady Smith said none of it was normal or acceptable. It was simply abusive.

Survivors and the school respond

The Edinburgh Academy Survivors Group welcomed the findings and thanked Lady Smith for an accurate and thoughtful account. The school, which apologised in 2023 for brutal and unrestrained historical abuse, said it was committed to facing up to the wrongs of the past.

Laura Connor, a partner at Thompsons Solicitors Scotland who represents a number of survivors, said the school's current leadership has apologised but been difficult and uncooperative when it comes to civil claims. She said that must end.

Rector Barry Welsh called the report sombre reading. He repeated the school's apology and said it continues to support survivors as fully as it can while educating current pupils in a caring environment.

NSPCC Scotland said the report makes grim reading. With the inquiry moving into its final stages, it said, the recommendations must bring lasting change, with schools and other organisations putting child protection first.

Scotland's child abuse inquiry, set up in October 2015, investigates how children in care were abused. Lady Smith has already reported on other schools, children's homes and orphanages.

Source: BBC News