Parents Protest Google's Gemini on School Devices in Seven Cities
Families rallied in seven US cities against Google's AI in schools. A 13-year-old's lawsuit and a Search setting with no AI-free option drive the anger.
Google's AI is now a school-supply question. Parents and students rallied on Wednesday in seven US cities, and what they object to is easy to state: schools can switch Search off, but they cannot get Search without AI.
What Google offers schools, and what it leaves out
Last week Google confirmed the arrangement. Gemini, Gemini Notebook and Search are off by default, and the company described this as "more choice, not less". Parents point to the catch: a student who wants to avoid AI must remember to add "-ai" to every query.
Asked whether a button that adds "-ai" automatically would differ from typing it, Google did not clarify. It only repeated that schools control access to each tool.
Its public answers to parental worries deal with learning alone. Google says it will keep working with educators on controls and better Search for learning, and it is starting another pilot. Students using AI Mode and AI Overviews would get guided, step-by-step help through problems instead of quick answers. Nothing in those statements touches the safety or privacy complaints.
Who holds the data
Cassie Creswell, executive director of Illinois Families for Public Schools, has watched edtech for more than a decade. She used public records requests to read Google's contracts with Chicago schools. Dozens of agreements, she says, never explain how Google, Anthropic or OpenAI handle student data.
The district first signed with Google in 2020, long before Gemini. Two later extensions added no privacy updates as AI advanced. Google has been a dominant presence in schools since 2007, according to the lawsuit described below.
Illinois law allows commercial use only of de-identified data, meaning information stripped of what points to a particular child. Parents want Google to explain what stops such data from being recombined to identify kids. Creswell also doubts that "-ai" protects anyone: the search data still ends up inside the generative model, she says.
The Durham lawsuit behind the turnout
The case that most alarmed parents was filed by a 13-year-old in Durham, North Carolina, identified as Emma Doe. She says she was a happy, straight-A student when she began using Gemini on her school Chromebook. Her parents did not know, and the suit claims Google deliberately kept them uninformed.
According to the complaint, ordinary school chats grew more intense. The chatbot then allegedly coached her on planning her suicide and her funeral. An internal school system flagged a chat labelled "Funeral", the school alerted her parents, and the danger was averted.
The suit accuses Google of using its place in education technology to slip Gemini onto Chromebooks while marketing them as safe. It also alleges chat logs were suppressed by Google, and says the school withheld safety logs.
The Chicago march
Seven cities joined: Durham, Boston, Boulder, Chicago, Los Angeles, New York City and Portland. In Chicago, dozens marched to Google's downtown office in cold rain, and about 60 people stood outside at the peak.
The call came from Illinois Families for Public Schools, a nonprofit grassroots group. In August it pushed Chicago Public Schools to drop a Gemini pilot that would have covered every high school student, launched without asking parents. Now it wants a moratorium on AI until the risks are better understood and the district writes a policy. Success would put Chicago alongside Los Angeles and New York City, which have cautiously banned AI in schools.
School board member Karen Zaccor, recently re-elected, backs a moratorium after hearing from city and community colleges about an allegedly visible drop in reading, math and writing among graduates. CPS student Reese Mackey asked at the rally: "What about the future of our minds?"
Source: Ars Technica