Companies Switch From Buybacks to Issuing Stock
US firms were net buyers of their own shares in 2024. Acadian says they are net sellers now, which adds supply just as Anthropic's IPO tests demand.
Anthropic's IPO is testing demand for new shares just as US companies sell more of their own stock than they take back. The four-year-old bull market has more supply to absorb.
A debut that cooled quickly
Anthropic, a frontier AI laboratory, sold its IPO shares at $83 each, above the expected range, and raised $81 billion. Early enthusiasm was strong. On Friday the stock fell and pulled the wider market down with it.
Mega-deals on the list
SpaceX took in $85.7 billion in its June IPO once underwriters exercised their overallotment. Alphabet announced an $84.8 billion equity raise the same month, to help pay for its AI infrastructure buildout.
Meta priced a $25 billion common-stock offering in October, along with $12.5 billion of mandatory convertible preferred shares. Oracle filed to sell $20 billion of stock through an at-the-market programme and put another $10 billion of common shares on the market in November.
Why a shrinking share count helped prices
For years some investors have cited the shrinking stock market as a reason prices could keep rising. A buyback removes shares from trading, so more money chases fewer shares. It also lifts earnings per share, since the share count in that ratio falls. With issuance, the effect runs the other way and becomes a possible headwind.
The shift in Acadian's numbers
Owen Lamont, a portfolio manager at Acadian Asset Management, wrote in a letter to investors this month that US corporations went from repurchasing in 2024 to issuing today. His question: "Why is the smart money selling?"
Net new issuance equalled 3.1% of total market capitalisation as of late last week, per an Acadian analysis. That is below the peaks of the tech bubble and the covid bubble. Even so, the analysis says the era of repurchases is over.
Before 2026, Lamont wrote, firms were net repurchasers, consistent with viewing their shares as undervalued. Today they issue on net, "for whatever reason".
What earlier research suggests
A 2000 paper by Malcolm Baker and Jeffrey Wurgler found that low market returns tended to follow years when firms issued more equity than debt. That hinted managers time the market. The equity share they track peaked near 18% in 2021. It has climbed lately but sits under that high, Lamont wrote.
Federal Reserve data on gross stock and bond issuance show a similar order of events. Debt rose first, in 2020, and equity followed in 2021. Debt began climbing again in 2024, and equity surged in 2026.
Source: CNBC