Judge Blocks Closure of East Potomac Park for Trump Golf Plan
A federal judge has paused the plan to close East Potomac Park in Washington, DC, for a Trump-backed golf overhaul. She found the government's reasons pretextual.
A federal judge has stopped work at East Potomac Park, a public golf course in Washington, DC. The order delays Donald Trump's plan to rebuild it as a championship-level course.
What the judge ordered
In a 30-page decision, US district judge Ana Reyes temporarily blocked a closure planned for Sunday. Trump said in an 18 October social media post that the park would shut for 15 months to become "one of the Best and Most Spectacular Golf Courses anywhere in the World".
Reyes found that the administration's stated reasons were pretextual. She also ruled that it broke at least two federal laws in order to meet an arbitrary deadline.
"The government proposes to close a historic park, daily enjoyed by Washingtonians of all stripes, indefinitely," she wrote.
The park stays open. The judge wrote that the administration need not keep golf running, but it cannot treat the end of golf as grounds for locking the public out.
Three courses and a running loop
The park lies near the Jefferson Memorial, about two miles south of the White House. Its three courses add up to 36 holes. There is also a miniature course, and cyclists and runners use a paved loop.
The redesign would merge them into one 18-hole course. Trump has said the redesigned course could stage tournaments like the US Open and the Ryder Cup, and that the public would still have access. Plaintiffs argue it would change the character of the course and make it unaffordable. The president denies that.
A lawsuit with a record of clashes
The case was brought by the DC Preservation League, a historic preservation group. Its lawyers at Democracy Forward represent the league and two local residents. They earlier won a ruling from Reyes that barred the National Park Service from cutting trees or making other irreversible changes without advance notice.
Relations between the judge and Justice Department lawyers have been tense. Last month Reyes said the removal of hundreds of trees, and the failure to tell the group, had cost the government all its credibility. She has ordered an ethics investigation into whether government lawyers repeatedly misled her about the closure timeline.
The Justice Department has accused her of overstepping and of belittling its lawyers, and asked her to step aside. She refused. Democracy Forward welcomed the ruling and called the plan one of the president's vanity projects. The Interior Department, Justice Department and White House did not immediately comment.
Reyes was appointed by Joe Biden. Courts have also been asked to rule on other Trump projects for the capital: the White House ballroom, his name on the Kennedy Center and a new arch. This order is the latest pushback from the judiciary.
For Trump, who owns golf courses around the world, the park fits a broader wish to put his own architectural stamp on the capital.
Source: the Guardian