NHS England Pulls List Claiming 137 Trusts Gain From Palantir
After 29 trusts said they were not live or not using the Palantir-built platform, NHS England removed its list of trusts "realising benefits".
Ministers are deciding whether Palantir's £330m NHS contract should run until 2029, and a row has opened over the evidence used to promote it. NHS England has deleted a claim that 137 hospital trusts are benefiting from the company's data platform.
Who wants the deal ended
Unison, the health workers' union, wants the contract ended. Its general secretary, Andrea Egan, said an extension would be "completely unacceptable and a betrayal of staff and patients". Palantir has said ending its contract would be "putting politics above patients".
A report last week said ministers planned to extend the deal, and the lobbying around it has been intense. Palantir has hired the Labour peer Tom Watson as a full-time lobbyist. He recently wrote to health secretary Yvette Cooper saying the company wanted to help "build Britain's sovereign technological capability".
Several groups have also written to the prime minister, Andy Burnham, and Cooper: the Doctors Association UK, Medact, Amnesty UK and Just Treatment. They oppose the reported plan to give Palantir two more years while the NHS moves to UK-based technology. In their view the deal could be ended safely in 2027, using a part of the contract called the termination assistance period.
What the deleted list claimed
NHS England had published a list of trusts described as "live" with the platform and "realising benefits" from it. The platform is a federated data system. It is meant to improve patient outcomes, make operating theatres more efficient and speed up bed discharges.
Then 29 trusts told the Guardian the platform was not live where they work, or that they were not using any of its applications. The list appears to have been taken down. A less detailed page now says early users are "already seeing real results – reduced admin, faster patient pathways, and more time for care".
The Medact campaign group had been researching the technology's use. It sent freedom of information requests to every hospital and integrated care board in England. Rhiannon Mihranian Osborne, an NHS doctor and Medact spokesperson, said she was relieved to see the pages go. She asked why NHS England spent years promoting the alleged benefits on shaky evidence.
A regulator already watching
The Office for Statistics Regulation says it is examining NHS claims about how widely the system is used. Critics say those claims make it look more embedded than it is. The regulator had earlier warned that NHS England had no evidence for a claim that the technology helped deliver more than 100,000 extra operations.
Ben Coleman, a Labour MP on the Commons health and social care select committee, called it "troubling" that the 137 trusts were listed and the list then apparently pulled. He said that when NHS England makes claims without checking them, it destroys trust. He wants Palantir dropped in favour of an open health data platform that trusts and British tech firms could build tools on.
A senior Labour MP warned that the move threatened public trust. NHS England did not respond to requests for comment.
Source: the Guardian