SEC's New NIL Template Draws Fire From Agents
Agents say the SEC's standardized NIL license agreement heavily favors schools. Some notable extensions are reportedly on hold, and schools cannot edit the template without league approval.
Agents are pushing back hard on the standardized name, image and likeness license agreements the SEC has adopted. Some now say they cannot sign the template, which could slow multi-year deals as college football contract talks heat up.
Extensions stall
The practical risk is a chill on long deals. Agents say a player who expects to outplay his contract has little reason to commit for years when the school need not renegotiate. 247Sports says it has heard that several notable extensions are already on hold. A fourth agent put it bluntly: "The current SEC template we have -- we can't sign."
Inside the league, views are mixed. Front office officials were united in calling the contracts team-friendly, and some liked the shift away from a time when agents held the leverage. Several predicted the harshest sections would never be applied, a view agents rejected. Timing was the main worry, since the 2027 recruiting class, roster renegotiations and portal prep are all under way. The SEC did not respond to 247Sports' interview request.
The money terms
247Sports reviewed the agreement and spoke with more than a dozen agent, legal and front office sources. Several agents who represent double-digit SEC players called the template "unconscionable".
A 50% liquidated damages clause is seen as high-end. Take a three-year, $10 million deal that pays $2 million in the first year. If he walks away after one year, he would owe $4 million, double his pay. Signing bonuses vest monthly, so unvested money could be clawed back on top of that.
Under section 3.3, a school may cut or hold back payments when an athlete's conduct "materially diminishes" the value of his NIL rights. The athlete gets 10 days to cure. Illinois law professor Michael H. LeRoy likened it to the baseball contract that a New York court threw out in 1890 in the case of John Montgomery Ward.
Section 6.22 would let schools terminate if a law such as the Protect College Sports Act pushes them over a spending cap and no new deal is reached within 10 days.
Contact limits, the portal and edits
The agreement bars athletes and their representatives from talking to other schools while the contract runs. Any approach must be reported to the school, and a violation is a material breach. An athlete being named on a portal list that an agent circulates to other programs triggers it too.
On the transfer portal, schools would not have to enter a player until after the team's last competition during the term. That appears to conflict with NCAA bylaws. Oregon law professor David Weber said the provision's validity would be for a court to settle.
Schools have been told that any edits to the standard contract need league approval, and even approved edits could take up to two weeks.
Source: CBS Sports