Six Nations and Sanzaar Face World Rugby Fight Over Relegation
Some unions want protection from relegation in the Nations Championship, which World Rugby says must be an open league from 2030. Reopening the 2023 vote carries risk.
A new fight is brewing between World Rugby and the unions over the Nations Championship. Some unions want to make sure none of them can drop out of the competition, while World Rugby expects an open league from 2030.
F10 and the fear of the second tier
The 10 leading unions have set up a company called F10. It will run the Nations Championship and sell broadcast and commercial rights for all competitions except the World Cup, which remains World Rugby's property. The launch of F10 has raised a worry in other parts of the sport. Some of the founders, Wales and Italy in particular, may want rules that keep them out of the second-tier Nations Cup, a World Rugby competition.
F10 unions fear financial loss if they play in the second tier. Italy and Fiji are the lowest-ranked teams after four rounds of the inaugural Nations Championship. Georgia and the USA lead the Nations Cup.
For Wales the stakes are plain. Abi Tierney, the Welsh Rugby Union chief executive, has said it would be "cataclysmic" if Wales were relegated.
What was agreed in 2023
The World Rugby Council approved the Nations Championship in Paris before the 2023 World Cup final. The condition was that the competition would turn into an open league in 2030. All sides could be relegated, and one promotion place would go to a Nations Cup team. Japan and Fiji hold invitational status for the first three editions, until 2030.
The vote needed a 75% majority. It got 41 votes for and 10 against, about 80%. People who were at the vote told the Guardian that a move to ringfence the founding members would need council approval. In their view it would alter the terms set three years ago. Reopening the debate would be risky for the unions, since it could throw the tournament into turmoil.
Money, rights and the leadership view
Smaller unions, and World Rugby, want the Nations Cup commercial rights sold together with the Nations Championship, which would give them a share of the proceeds. The Nations Championship has more than 80 broadcast deals this year, made before F10 existed. The Nations Cup has 13, with many games streamed on World Rugby's RugbyPass TV.
None of this is new ground. World Rugby proposed the Nations Championship almost a decade ago, and the unions turned it down because they would not accept relegation. World Rugby also first floated selling commercial rights jointly, which the 10 biggest unions have now set up themselves.
The Six Nations' official position is that relegation arrives in 2030 as planned, though the exact mechanism is undecided. Six Nations sources say the main open issue is the size of a parachute payment for a relegated union. Individual unions are still lobbying for exemptions. In World Rugby's plan, the loser of the 2030 playoff between sixth-placed teams of the two hemispheres would be replaced by the Nations Cup winners.
Rugby Football Union chief executive Bill Sweeney said a review group chaired by Brett Robinson is looking at how promotion and relegation can be set up. "The basic premise is still the same," he said.
Source: The Guardian