NewsDesk World

Press releases and business news from around the world

Brought to you with help from

UK Under-16 Social Media Ban May Reach YouTube Kids

Technology · ·

Draft regulations could pull up to 150 platforms into Britain's under-16 ban, including sites ministers had signalled would be spared.

UK Under-16 Social Media Ban May Reach YouTube Kids

Britain's planned social media ban for under-16s may be much wider than promised. Sources briefed on the government's draft rules say it could sweep in YouTube Kids and other services that were thought to be exempt.

Up to 150 platforms in scope

One source close to the talks said the regulations now under consideration could cover up to 150 platforms. Games platforms such as Lego Play are among them. The ban is due to take effect in March.

The rules go to cabinet for signoff this week. Culture secretary Lisa Nandy is due to bring them before parliament in December. The Commons will not need to pass a new law, as the rules will be added to the Children's Wellbeing and Schools Act.

The government has briefed tech companies, industry groups and MPs on a working proposal built around recommender systems and user-generated content. Those are the features that suggest videos, songs or posts and let users upload their own material. Spotify has some of both. It could technically fall inside the ban, and it has asked for reassurance that it will not, since it is not primarily a social platform.

Why ministers want a broad net

Ministers are understood to want rules with no gaps. In Australia, critics argue, the ban left gaps: teenagers moved to other platforms, and some kept messaging through innocuous-looking sites.

One industry source argued that nearly every site runs some recommender system, which makes the rules too broad, and that the government wants them airtight for any eventuality.

When Keir Starmer announced the ban in June, the government said it would not cover educational services, e-commerce platforms or music streaming. It promised a narrowly defined list of exemptions, kept under review. Tech firms now say that without the recommender algorithm their sites could not function.

One industry source called it unsustainable that eBay, Lego, YouTube Kids and Spotify cannot tell whether they comply.

A second wave aimed at shopping apps

Ministers are also looking at a second set of regulations for spring. It could cover e-commerce platforms such as Vinted, eBay and Depop. MPs and campaigners have told Nandy that teenagers and groomers can find ways to talk to each other on sites that allow messages from unknown or anonymous users.

Nandy said in interviews on Sunday that the government was considering bringing Vinted and similar platforms into scope. Officials then held a call with retailers on Tuesday, and several are understood to have objected strongly. Another industry figure called it illogical to keep allowing WhatsApp and iMessage while banning Vinted and eBay for having messaging.

The online safety minister has also confirmed that the next set of rules will look at "features and functions". He said Spotify has added a way for strangers to talk on its platform. A company source said Spotify messaging is limited to known friends and family for users aged 16 and over.

The off-ramp

Online safety minister Ian Murray told MPs last week that a platform could get itself off the banned list by stripping harmful or addictive features out of its service. His words: "The way back is to comply with the regulations and fall out of scope."

He said YouTube Kids and Lego Play would need to show they have no harmful algorithms. Industry bodies argue that is impossible for a service like YouTube Kids, which stops working without its recommender system. Companies are expected to be briefed on the final proposal in the coming days by the culture department and No 10.

Source: the Guardian