NewsDesk World

Press releases and business news from around the world

Published thanks to our backers

Study Finds Safety Gaps Between NHS and Private Hospitals

Medical & Health · Updated ·

Researchers say quality checks work inside hospitals but fail between them, so concerns about a doctor can go unshared. Most Paterson Inquiry reforms are still not in place.

Study Finds Safety Gaps Between NHS and Private Hospitals

A surgeon who operates in both an NHS and a private hospital can leave each employer seeing only half of his record. A new study says that gap is still open, six years after the Paterson Inquiry.

The case behind the reforms

The Paterson Inquiry followed the case of a surgeon sentenced to 20 years in prison. Across NHS and private hospitals in the West Midlands, he had performed operations nobody had approved and that hundreds of patients never needed.

The inquiry set out a series of changes to how care quality and patient safety are assured. The government largely accepted them. Researchers from the universities of York, Manchester and Birmingham now report that most have not been carried out.

Checks that stop at the hospital door

The team found that quality and safety assurance works inside individual organisations and falters between them. Patients, the report says, depend too much on each specialist to volunteer their own results and worries to the hospitals employing them.

Annual appraisals have been required of every doctor since 2012, with a fitness-to-practise check every five years. These are mostly carried out at the NHS hospital where the doctor works. Private work is not always covered, and private hospitals do not always receive the outcome.

Patients seen in both sectors face a similar break: their medical records often do not travel with them. The authors want every hospital to feed into one shared care record and see the same files.

An answer to the privacy worry

Hospitals have held back from sharing, the report says, because of misplaced fears about GDPR and confidentiality. Its proposed fix is a clear legal duty. Any hospital with concerns about a doctor would have to pass them to every other hospital where that doctor practises.

One database covering all hospital care, NHS and private, was an Inquiry recommendation too. Doctors, hospitals and patients were meant to use it to check quality and safety. The data is gathered but not shared well, and the database has yet to appear.

Kieran Walshe, a professor at the University of Manchester, said most care in both sectors is safe and the team found no difference in quality between them. The danger arises when something goes wrong. In his words, poor practice and serious harm “can happen for years before action is taken”.

His colleague Karen Bloor, a professor at the University of York's Centre for Health Economics, pointed out that many doctors work in both settings. Protecting patients, she said, takes complete data from both.

Walshe added that the inquiry asked for systems that pool data on a doctor's whole practice, wherever it happens, and raise concerns much sooner. Those reforms, he said, have not happened.

NHS money, private wards

Private hospitals deliver a growing share of NHS-funded care, mainly elective surgery, meaning planned operations. The study finds that the integrated care boards, which buy this care for the NHS, are short on both the capacity and the skills to oversee the contracts.

Source: Medical Xpress