Google Refuses to Pull Russell Brand's Prison Video
Google has turned down a UK request to remove a YouTube message Brand sent from prison. Labour MP Jess Phillips says a second online safety act is now likely.
Google has declined a UK government request to take down a video that Russell Brand sent from prison. Labour MP Jess Phillips, a former minister, says the government has no power to compel platforms to remove such content.
What Phillips says the law lacks
Phillips was a minister for safeguarding and violence against women and girls. Speaking on BBC Radio 4's Today programme, she said the Ofcom codes on women's safety online are voluntary. For tech companies, she said, voluntary codes are "the triumph of hope over experience".
She argued that the regulations the government would need to demand a takedown are almost certainly not in place. Her view is that a second online safety act could be needed, because earlier prisoners did not have massive YouTube followings. She called such an act very likely.
She also said pressure on companies such as Google will keep building. In her words, by leaving the video up Google shows the codes are not good enough, and the company would take it down if it wanted lighter regulation.
What the current act covers
The Online Safety Act became law in 2023. It targets illegal content and keeps under-18s away from material such as pornography that is not suitable for their age. The act is rolling out in phases, and a 2026 law changed the Ofcom codes. The act says nothing explicit about a prisoner posting online for an audience beyond the prison walls. Phillips accepts that, given Brand's platform, this gap is a problem.
Political reaction
On Thursday morning, ministers joined calls for Google to act. Andrea Simon, the victims' commissioner for London, had already made such a call. Children and families minister Josh MacAlister said he hoped Google would make the same choice as Meta. Meta, the parent company of Facebook, disabled Brand's accounts as harmful to the community.
Housing minister Matthew Pennycook told Sky News that prisoners already face a ban on statements to the media. He called this an exceptional case, in which MoJ ministers had asked for one specific piece of content to be removed.
Kemi Badenoch, the Conservative leader, voiced concern about prisoners using intermediaries to pass out messages. She still saw Brand's wife as a separate person and YouTube as a private platform. "Immediately demanding that private platforms take down without looking at whether a law has been broken is not where I would start from," she said.
The video and Google's answer
Days after Brand's conviction, his wife, Laura, posted a message from him to the couple's 6.6 million YouTube subscribers. In it he claimed he was not guilty of the sexual offences for which a jury had convicted him. The video has almost 850,000 views.
The Ministry of Justice opened an investigation into whether he broke prison rules. The government also asked Google, which owns YouTube, to remove the video. The request went through the Prison Service. Google refused, despite warnings that the clip was distressing survivors of sexual abuse.
A Google spokesperson said the company was aware of the new content and that its teams were investigating. The spokesperson added that Brand's channel was suspended from the YouTube partner program in September 2023, and it has been unable to earn money there since.
The Brand case has made the issue hard to ignore, but the concern is older. Stephen Yaxley-Lennon, the far-right activist known as Tommy Robinson, is another figure whose continued presence on social media has worried people before.
Source: the Guardian