NewsDesk World

Press releases and business news from around the world

Published with kind assistance from

England and Wales Plan to End Lifelong Disclosure of Childhood Crimes

Law & Justice · ·

Ministers propose that people convicted of robbery or violent disorder as children would no longer have to tell employers for life. The plan is open to consultation.

England and Wales Plan to End Lifelong Disclosure of Childhood Crimes

A government plan for England and Wales would end lifelong disclosure of childhood criminal records for many offences, including robbery and violent disorder. The proposals are out for consultation and are meant to cut the number of children in custody while helping young people into work.

A record that blocks work

Jobs that need a standard or enhanced DBS check include teaching, early years, social work, healthcare and transport work such as taxi driving. For those roles, an applicant has to disclose certain convictions, whatever their age at the time.

Ministers have discussed narrowing this duty for several years. In a 2017 review, David Lammy, the former justice secretary, named childhood records as one cause of the discrimination that black and minority people met in later life. Companies rank criminal convictions as the second-largest obstacle when they hire from disadvantaged backgrounds.

Campaigners welcomed the plan and said it would lift youth employment. Paula Harriott, chief executive of the charity Unlock, said it is neither proportionate nor fair that tens of thousands of people disclose childhood offences each year.

One woman's record

A 22-year-old identified only as Joanne spent 18 months in a young offender institution as a child. She said the reforms would have changed her life had they come earlier. She was convicted of several counts of affray and assault, the first at age 10, after being exploited by a gang that pushed her to sell drugs.

She told reporters in London that she wants to run her own residential care facility that employs people with lived experience. Her record from five and a half years ago still stands in the way, she said.

The new disclosure clock

Under the plan, an offender convicted before 18 of robbery, affray, actual bodily harm, violent disorder or supplying drugs to a child would no longer be bound to declare it for life. Without a custodial sentence, the duty would last five and a half years. A sentence of two years or less would mean 11 years. A longer custodial sentence would keep the lifetime obligation.

A conviction that ends in a fine would no longer need disclosing at all. Today the law requires it for six months.

Justice minister Jake Richards plans to shrink the list of offences that carry a lifelong duty. He told the Guardian that where it is safe, people should have second chances to contribute to work and turn their back on crime. In his words, the current system does not tell offences committed as a child from those committed as an adult.

Out-of-court cases and repeat offending

The package goes beyond that list. Ministers also want to end automatic disclosure of any out-of-court resolution.

A second rule would go too. Today, a new conviction during the rehabilitation period stretches the time before the first one counts as spent, meaning no longer needing to be declared. That extension would end.

Source: the Guardian